Skip to main content
HomeBlogData Engineering

Private Cloud vs. Public Cloud: Which One to Choose?

Cloud computing offers public, private, and hybrid models, each with distinct advantages and tradeoffs, requiring careful consideration to select the right fit for your organization.
Jun 2024  · 9 min read

In recent years, cloud technology has seen huge growth due to the increased data storage and security needs of the current data-driven world. Organizations collect large amounts of data from various sources, so as data practitioners, we need powerful computer resources and scalable storage solutions to analyze the data effectively.

Cloud computing delivers on-demand IT services over the Internet. Organizations can access computing power, databases, storage, networking, and software without purchasing and maintaining their own infrastructure.

In this article, we'll explore the three primary cloud models—private, public, and hybrid—outlining their key characteristics, advantages, and drawbacks. By the end, we'll better understand which model best suits our specific data needs.

Public Cloud

Of the three primary cloud models, the public cloud is perhaps the most well-known and widely adopted. But what exactly defines this model, and what are its key characteristics? Let's take a closer look.

Definition and characteristics

Public clouds are owned and operated by third-party providers, such as Amazon Web Services (AWS), Microsoft Azure, and Google Cloud Platform (GCP). In this model, we can access a shared, scalable, elastic, and flexible broad set of services and resources on a pay-as-you-go system. Consequently, they are cost-effective and provide suitable tools for variable workloads and rapid scalability. 

Vendors operate a global network of data centers located in multiple regions and availability zones which allow us to deploy applications and services closer to us, minimizing the latency and improving our application’s performance. Public cloud providers offer high-speed, low-latency connectivity and network interconnectivity options to enable data transfer between regions and availability zones. 

Using public cloud services, we can access computing, storage, databases, networking, analytics, machine learning, and security, among other things, without having to worry about the complexity of managing infrastructure. Moreover, these services implement security controls and encryption mechanisms that protect our data to meet compliance with data protection certifications. 

Advantages and disadvantages of the public cloud

Let’s now take a closer look at the advantages and disadvantages of the public cloud:

Advantages

Disadvantages

Cost-effectiveness: No upfront infrastructure costs, pay-as-you-go pricing

Security concerns: Shared infrastructure raises potential data isolation and access risks

Ease of use: Intuitive interfaces, self-service portals, and APIs for faster deployment

Compliance issues: Limited control and visibility over infrastructure can pose compliance challenges for regulated industries

Scalability: Easy to adjust resources up or down to meet demand

Limited customization: Standardized infrastructure and service options may not suit all needs

Reliability: High availability and disaster recovery capabilities

Vendor lock-in: Migrating data and applications between different public cloud providers can be complex and costly

Private Cloud

Now that we've explored the public cloud let's turn our attention to another popular option: the private cloud. How does it differ from its public counterpart, and what advantages does it offer?

Definition and characteristics

Private clouds provide single-tenant dedicated infrastructure and resources for our exclusive use, ensuring enhanced security, more isolation, greater control, and customization options. They involve higher upfront costs but are suitable for projects or organizations with sensitive workloads, strict regulatory compliance, and specific performance requirements.

The private cloud can be physically located in our on-site data center or hosted by a third-party service provider. Even if hosted remotely by a third party, this model offers us isolation from users, which allows us to have full control over granting access permissions, network configurations, and security policies. Moreover, we can integrate private clouds with public cloud resources and other cloud deployment models.

Advantages and disadvantages of the private cloud

Let’s see what are the advantages and disadvantages of using the private cloud:

Advantages

Disadvantages

Control: Enhanced visibility and governance over environment, enabling custom security measures and policies.

Cost: Significant upfront investments in infrastructure and tools.

Compliance: Greater control over data residency and security facilitates meeting industry regulations.

Scalability: Limited by finite resources and capacity within the dedicated infrastructure.

Customization: Dedicated resources offer flexibility in tailoring infrastructure and security to specific needs.

Maintenance: Requires dedicated IT staff and resources, increasing operational costs.

Performance: Dedicated resources can be optimized for specific workloads, potentially improving performance.

Limited Mobile Access: Security layers may hinder mobile access.

Hybrid Cloud

Hybrid clouds were developed as a response to the increased need to integrate computing, storage, and services in different computing environments with enough capacity and improved overall performance. Hybrid cloud refers to the combination of public cloud, private cloud, and on-premises infrastructure into a single flexible solution. This combined model gives us the following benefits:

  • Flexibility: We can choose the appropriate cloud environment for each workload. We can keep sensitive data and critical workloads in a private cloud to meet strict security and compliance while leveraging the scalability and agility of public clouds for less sensitive workloads.
  • Scalability: We can scale resources up or down dynamically based on demand and, at the same time, maintain control over core infrastructure in private clouds.
  • Cost-effectiveness: We can optimize costs by allocating workloads to the most cost-effective cloud environment. On the one hand, we can use private clouds for workloads with predictable usage. In parallel, we can leverage public clouds for variable workloads and seasonal peaks.
  • Security and control: A hybrid cloud offers the security and control of private clouds enforcing strict access controls, encryption policies, and compliance measures for sensitive applications while benefiting from enhanced security features and certifications offered by public cloud providers.

Choosing the Right Cloud Model

Choosing the right cloud model is an important decision. To make an informed choice, we need to carefully weigh several key factors:

  • Business objectives: We need to ensure the chosen model aligns with our overall goals, taking into account flexibility, scalability, and cost-effectiveness.
  • Security & compliance: We must assess the sensitivity of our data and any relevant industry regulations to determine if we require the enhanced security of a private cloud or can leverage the flexibility of a hybrid model.
  • Budget: We should evaluate the total cost of ownership, comparing pricing structures like subscription-based and pay-as-you-go models, and factor in potential hidden costs.
  • Scalability: Let's analyze our growth projections and workload variability to select a model that can adapt seamlessly to our changing needs.
  • Control over infrastructure: We need to determine the desired level of control we want over configurations, security policies, and hardware, considering whether the flexibility of a public cloud or the autonomy of a private cloud better suits our requirements.

Let’s summarize what we’ve learned and do a head-to-head comparison between public, private, and hybrid cloud models:

Feature

Public Cloud

Private Cloud

Hybrid Cloud

Ownership

Third-party provider

Organization itself

Combination of public and private

Infrastructure

Shared

Dedicated

Combination of shared and dedicated

Cost

Pay-as-you-go, typically lower upfront costs

Higher upfront investment, ongoing maintenance

Varies depending on usage and configuration

Scalability

Highly scalable, resources easily adjustable

Limited scalability, depends on internal resources

Scalable, leveraging both models

Security

Shared responsibility model, security measures implemented by provider

Full control over security measures

Customizable security depending on workload

Compliance

May be challenging for highly regulated industries

Easier to meet specific compliance requirements

Can address compliance needs through segregation

Customization

Limited, standardized options

High degree of customization

Customizable based on workload allocation

Ideal Use Cases

Variable workloads, rapid scaling, testing and development, non-sensitive data

Sensitive data, strict compliance requirements, high performance needs

Mix of sensitive and non-sensitive workloads, fluctuating demands

Conclusion

In recent years, both private and public cloud adoption has grown exponentially. Although they serve a common purpose, they have different characteristics that make them suitable for different requirements. While private clouds provide more data isolation, control over infrastructure, and higher customization, public clouds offer us higher accessibility, ease of setup, and affordability.

Choosing between public and private clouds depends on our needs, priorities, and objectives. By aligning our cloud strategy with our business goals and requirements, we can make an informed decision that helps us maximize the benefits of cloud computing.

If you want to deepen your understanding of cloud computing and further understand the difference between public vs. private models, take a look at the following resources:

FAQs

What is the main difference between private and public clouds?

The main difference lies in ownership and accessibility. A private cloud is dedicated to a single tenant, while a public cloud is shared among multiple users.

Are there differences in security between private and public clouds?

Private clouds are more suitable for sensitive data and compliance requirements. Public clouds provide robust security but can raise some concerns about data privacy and control.

What are the costs of private and public cloud?

Public clouds have better cost-effectiveness, while private clouds require more upfront investment.

Which applications are more suitable for each cloud?

Private clouds are more suitable for critical applications with sensitive data, while public clouds are better for scalable web applications.

How does scalability compare between private and public clouds?

Public clouds offer virtually unlimited scalability, while private clouds have finite resources.


Photo of Maria Eugenia Inzaugarat
Author
Maria Eugenia Inzaugarat
Topics

Learn data engineering with these courses!

course

Introduction to Data Engineering

4 hours
110.6K
Learn about the world of data engineering in this short course, covering tools and topics like ETL and cloud computing.
See DetailsRight Arrow
Start Course
See MoreRight Arrow
Related

blog

Cloud Computing and Architecture for Data Scientists

Discover how data scientists use the cloud to deploy data science solutions to production or to expand computing power.
Alex Castrounis's photo

Alex Castrounis

13 min

blog

What is Serverless Computing?

Learn about serverless computing, a cloud model where cloud providers manage infrastructure and allow software developers to ship applications quickly.
Adejumo Ridwan Suleiman's photo

Adejumo Ridwan Suleiman

13 min

blog

Google Cloud for Data Scientists: Harnessing Cloud Resources for Data Analysis

How can using Google Cloud make data analysis easier? We explore examples of companies that have already experienced all the benefits.
Oleh Maksymovych's photo

Oleh Maksymovych

9 min

blog

Data Lakes vs. Data Warehouses

Understand the differences between the two most popular options for storing big data.
DataCamp Team's photo

DataCamp Team

4 min

podcast

Data Science in the Cloud

Paige Bailey, senior Cloud Developer Advocate at Microsoft, reports from the frontier of cloud-based data science technologies.
Hugo Bowne-Anderson's photo

Hugo Bowne-Anderson

60 min

tutorial

Snowflake vs AWS: Choosing the Right Cloud Data Warehouse Solution

Discover why Snowflake and AWS are the top cloud data warehouses. Compare their unique features, limitations, and pricing to find the best fit for your needs.
Gus Frazer's photo

Gus Frazer

13 min

See MoreSee More